Process Engineering

ASHRAE Level 2 Energy Audit: What Levels 1 to 3 Cover

ASHRAE Level 2 energy audit — mechanical plant room with chilled water pumps, plate heat exchanger and a clamp-on flow meter | Global Formulation
A mechanical plant room with pumps, heat exchanger and a clamp-on flow meter: a Level 2 audit surveys and breaks down the use of systems like these.

A facility owner is asked for an ASHRAE Level 2 energy audit, and the quotations arrive with different scopes, different deliverables and different ideas of what Level 2 means. An ASHRAE Level 2 energy audit is an energy survey and analysis that breaks consumption down by system and costs the practical efficiency measures, building on a Level 1 walk-through. The level decides how firm the savings numbers are, because ASHRAE intends Level 1 estimates of savings and cost to be qualitative. This guide explains what Levels 1 to 3 cover, how to choose between them, what an audit includes and where the standard stops. It draws on ASHRAE's published preview of Standard 211-2018, its 2024 addendum and the US Department of Energy's audit-process material. The approach reflects the ASHRAE energy audit support that Global Formulation provides to facility owners.

ASHRAE Level 2 Energy Audit and Standard 211: What the Standard Is

Audit levels are older than the standard that now defines them. ASHRAE's Procedures for Commercial Building Energy Audits, known as the Green Book, introduced Levels 1, 2 and 3 as shorthand for scoping an audit. It left much room for interpretation. ANSI/ASHRAE/ACCA Standard 211-2018, reaffirmed in 2023, replaces that looseness with defined procedures and minimum reporting, and in the United States it is voluntary unless a jurisdiction makes it mandatory.

  • Purpose — to establish consistent practices for conducting and reporting commercial building energy audits, with a common scope of work for each level that owners can use in a contract.
  • Minimum, not best practice — the committee describes the standard as a minimum performance standard, so good practice can go beyond it.
  • Two intended users — building owners who specify a defined scope in a contract or bid, and government bodies that require audits. The authority having jurisdiction can adjust the scope, procedures and reporting.
  • Who attests compliance — a qualified energy auditor certifies compliance on a form in the standard.

ASHRAE's fact sheet on Standards 180 and 211 lists Washington D.C., Washington State, Oregon, Boulder, Atlanta, Philadelphia and Seattle among the jurisdictions that use the standard. Addendum a, approved on 31 October 2024, retitles the standard Standard for Commercial Building Energy Audits and Decarbonization Assessments. It limits decarbonization work to Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions. This guide covers the energy audit levels only.

Knowing what the standard is only helps once you know what separates the three levels, which is the next question.

ASHRAE Level 1 vs Level 2 vs Level 3: What Each Audit Level Covers

The three levels are cumulative. Each successive level builds on the preceding one, so an ASHRAE Level 2 audit, also written ASHRAE Level II, includes everything an ASHRAE Level 1 energy audit requires. What changes at each step is the depth of the survey, the rigour of the calculation and how far the numbers can be trusted for a spending decision. ASHRAE's names for the levels are walk-through analysis, energy survey and analysis, and detailed analysis of capital-intensive modifications.

The three ASHRAE energy audit levels are cumulative Three nested boxes show that each ASHRAE audit level contains the one before it. The innermost box is Level 1, a walk-through analysis with utility bill analysis, benchmarking, a brief site survey, no-cost and low-cost measures and qualitative estimates. The middle box is Level 2, an energy survey and analysis that adds a detailed survey, energy use by system, costed practical measures, simple payback and operations and maintenance impacts. The outer box is Level 3, a detailed analysis of capital-intensive modifications that adds field data gathering, sub-metering, detailed modelling, life-cycle cost analysis and an auditor risk assessment. Level 3: Detailed analysis of capital-intensive modifications Level 2: Energy survey and analysis Level 1 Walk-through analysis Utility bill analysis Benchmarking Brief site survey No-cost and low-cost measures Qualitative estimates Adds at Level 2 Detailed survey Energy use by system Costed practical measures Simple payback Operations and maintenance impacts Adds at Level 3 Field data gathering Sub-metering Detailed modelling Life-cycle cost analysis Auditor risk assessment
Figure 1. The three ASHRAE audit levels are cumulative. The descriptions are summaries of Standard 211 and the US Department of Energy guidance, not quotations.
LevelWhat the work involvesWhat you receiveWhen to select it
Level 1: walk-through analysisUtility bill analysis and benchmarking against peer buildings, a brief survey and an initial estimate by hand calculationNo-cost and low-cost measures, capital improvements worth studying and a summary report, with savings and cost that are qualitativeWhen the savings potential is in doubt, or to screen a portfolio before deeper audits
Level 2: energy survey and analysisA more detailed survey, a breakdown of energy use by system, initial modelling and cost and savings analysis for all practical measuresA costed list of measures with simple payback, operations and maintenance impacts and a list of capital-intensive optionsThe default level for most buildings, and the usual choice when you want measures to act on
Level 3: detailed analysis of capital-intensive modificationsMore field data gathering, including sub-metering, detailed modelling and life-cycle cost analysis, with a risk assessment by the auditorA detailed project cost and savings analysis for each capital measureFor large capital-intensive projects where the decision needs firm numbers

Simple benchmarking is sometimes called a Level 0 audit, and virtual or remote audits have become common. The standard's authors treat these as initial screening and not as a replacement for an onsite audit by an experienced, qualified energy auditor. The Department of Energy's 2013 audit-process presentation adds that level definitions are not rigid and should capture the objectives of the assessment. Standard 211 later sharpened the boundaries between them.

Which ASHRAE Audit Level Do You Need? A Decision Framework

The right level follows from the decision the audit has to support. A screening question needs a cheaper, shallower answer than a capital replacement does, and paying for depth you will not use wastes budget. Buying too little depth is worse, because a report that cannot carry the decision gets repeated at the next level. The table matches common situations to levels.

Your situationLevelReason
You doubt that a building or site has worthwhile savingsLevel 1It identifies no-cost measures and shows whether a deeper audit is justified
You manage a portfolio and must rank sitesLevel 1, then Level 2 or 3 on the bestThe Department of Energy describes Level 1 as a screen for the deeper levels
You want a costed list of measures to act onLevel 2It costs all practical measures and is the default level for most buildings
You are deciding on a large capital replacement, such as chiller or boiler plantLevel 3It adds measured data, detailed modelling and life-cycle cost analysis
A city or authority requires an auditThe level named in the local ruleThe authority having jurisdiction can adjust the standard's scope and reporting
You hold only a benchmark or a remote reviewTreat as screeningIt does not replace an onsite audit by a qualified energy auditor

A staged approach works: Level 1 to rank, Level 2 to cost the measures, Level 3 only for the capital projects that survive. Each stage reuses the work of the one before, since the levels are cumulative.

What an ASHRAE Energy Audit Includes, and What Standard 211 Excludes

Standard 211 is a building standard. It applies to all buildings except single-family houses, multifamily structures of three stories or fewer above grade and manufactured houses. Within a building it lists the systems an audit covers where they exist, and it excludes three end uses. That boundary matters most to industrial owners, because a factory contains loads the standard does not reach.

The systems in scope, as applicable to the building, are:

  • Envelope and lighting — including infiltration pathways, and interior and exterior lighting.
  • HVAC and controls — cooling, heating, air distribution, ventilation and exhaust, and building automation systems.
  • Water and steam systems — heating, chilled, condenser and domestic water systems with their pumps, and steam systems.
  • Refrigeration and power — refrigeration other than food processing, onsite generation including renewables, and critical power systems.
  • Other building loads — data centres, conveyance, plug loads, laundries, food preparation, and pools and spas.

The standard excludes industrial processes, agricultural processes and irrigation from its end uses.

A factory is not automatically in scope Because industrial processes are excluded, an audit of a manufacturing site carried out to ASHRAE levels has to state its boundary. The usual approach is to apply the Level 1 to 3 structure to the building and its utility systems, and to agree in writing how process loads are treated. A boundary left unstated is a reason two quotations for the same site cannot be compared.

Within the building scope, process-driven spaces still shape the work. Cleanrooms and laboratories carry ventilation, pressure and cleanliness requirements that every measure must preserve, as our guide to cleanroom and GMP facility design explains. Condenser-water quality affects chiller and cooling-tower performance, which our guide to cooling tower water treatment covers. HVAC upgrades that follow an audit are engineered under our MEP, HVAC and fire protection engineering service. Larger capital measures move into design and delivery, as in our EPC and EPCM project management work.

How an ASHRAE Level 2 Energy Audit Runs: Data, Site Work and Analysis

An audit follows a fixed sequence, and each step depends on the data collected before it. The auditor needs a clean baseline from the utility records, a site visit to see how the systems really run, and a method for costing each measure. The standard sets the minimum content of that work, and the owner decides how much further to go. Seven steps make up the flow for a Level 2 audit.

  1. Agree the level, boundary and owner's criteria — the owner and the qualified energy auditor settle how recommendations will be judged, such as payback limits and operating constraints.
  2. Supply the utility data — benchmarking uses normalised consumption spanning at least 12 consecutive months and up to three years, where available, compared with similar buildings.
  3. Visit the site — the standard requires a site visit at every level, so a remote review alone cannot meet it.
  4. Survey the systems and break down the energy use — consumption is allocated to end uses, using sub-metering where it exists.
  5. Identify and qualify the measures — practical measures, meaning those that are technically feasible, are vetted for interactions with each other. The ones that give a net benefit become recommended measures.
  6. Cost and rank the measures — each measure receives a cost, a savings estimate and a simple payback, defined as initial cost divided by first-year savings.
  7. Check quality, present and sign — the auditor carries out quality assurance, presents the results to the owner and signs the compliance form.

Simple payback is a first screen, not a verdict. It ignores the life of the equipment and the cost of money, which is why Level 3 adds life-cycle cost analysis for capital decisions.

ASHRAE Level 2 energy audit process detail — clamp-on ultrasonic flow sensor and temperature sensor on an insulated chilled water pipe | Global Formulation
A clamp-on flow sensor and temperature sensor on an insulated pipe: short-term logging like this gives the measured data that replaces estimates in a detailed audit.

Why Energy Audits Disappoint: Bills That Do Not Reconcile and Savings That Never Appear

A disappointing audit has a gap between what was promised and what the owner can use. The gap opens at the baseline, the level, the measure interactions or the verification. Each has a plant consequence that appears after the report is delivered and the money is spent. The table lists the common failures with the step that prevents each.

What goes wrongConsequenceHow to prevent it
Utility bills do not match the meters or the recordsThe baseline is wrong, so every saving is measured from the wrong starting pointReconcile bills with records, use actual rates instead of blended ones, normalise for weather and explain historical spikes
No sub-metering to allocate useThe end-use breakdown rests on estimatesPlan sub-metering early; Level 3 relies on measured field data
Level 1 used to support an investment decisionSavings and cost are qualitative, so the capital case rests on soft numbersCommission Level 2 or Level 3 for any capital decision
Measures priced one by oneInteracting measures, such as lighting and cooling load, double count savingsVet measures for interactive effects before ranking them
Predicted savings do not appear after installationThe payback case fails and trust in the audit fallsState the assumptions behind every calculation and agree before installation how savings will be verified from the meters
Comfort complaints after a control changeOccupants or processes lose the conditions they needKeep ventilation, pressure and cleanliness requirements fixed whatever savings are proposed
A remote review sold as an auditNo site evidence stands behind the recommendationsTreat it as screening and require an onsite audit for any level

The Department of Energy's validation checklist covers many of these points: sanity checks, document review, costs with their sources, bills that match records and assumptions that seem reasonable. A buyer can apply the same checks to any report before accepting it.

Commissioning an ASHRAE Energy Audit: An Owner's Checklist

A well-specified audit request makes quotations comparable and protects the owner from a report that cannot be used. The specification is short, but every line removes a later argument. Work through the items below before inviting quotations. The checklist applies to any level.

  1. State the level and the reason — screening, a costed list of measures or a capital decision.
  2. Draw the facility boundary — which buildings and utility systems are in, and how process loads are treated.
  3. List the systems — the building systems from the scope list that exist on the site.
  4. Provide the data — utility bills for 12 to 36 months, interval data where available, drawings and equipment lists.
  5. Set the auditor's qualifications — ask how the auditor meets the standard's definition of a qualified energy auditor and any local rule. The definition combines audit experience with a recognised credential, a professional engineer or contractor status approved by the authority, or approval by the authority itself.
  6. Name the reporting format — the standard's forms where the authority requires them, or an agreed structure.
  7. State your criteria — payback limits, funding constraints and conditions that no measure can breach.
  8. Agree the verification plan — how savings will be confirmed from the meters after installation.

On delivery the owner should receive the baseline and benchmark, the end-use breakdown and the ranked measures with cost, savings, simple payback and stated assumptions. The report should also show how interactions were handled, the operations and maintenance impacts and the signed compliance form. At Level 3 it adds the model, the life-cycle cost analysis and the risk assessment. To check the work, pick two measures and re-derive the saving from the stated assumptions, then reconcile the baseline with your own bills.

ASHRAE Level 2 energy audit production scene — rooftop air handling units, ductwork and a cooling tower at a facility | Global Formulation
Rooftop air handling units and a cooling tower: heating, ventilation and cooling plant like this is the kind of equipment an ASHRAE audit surveys.

Owners who want energy audit services scoped to a level and a facility boundary can start from our ASHRAE energy audits service. It covers ASHRAE Level 1, 2 and 3 energy audits, industrial utility audits and savings verification. The checklist above is the brief to bring to that conversation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an ASHRAE Level 2 energy audit?

An ASHRAE Level 2 energy audit is an energy survey and analysis. It is more detailed than a walk-through, breaks energy use down by system and costs the practical efficiency measures.

It builds on Level 1, so everything a Level 1 audit requires is included. The Department of Energy describes it as the default audit level for most buildings.

What is the difference between ASHRAE Level 1, Level 2 and Level 3 audits?

Level 1 is a walk-through analysis built on utility bills and a brief survey, and its savings and cost estimates are qualitative. Level 2 adds a detailed survey, an energy breakdown by system and costed practical measures.

Level 3 is a detailed analysis of capital-intensive modifications, with more field data gathering, sub-metering, detailed modelling and life-cycle cost analysis. Each level includes the work of the one before it.

Which ASHRAE audit level do I need?

Choose the level from the decision the audit must support. Use Level 1 to screen a building or portfolio. Use Level 2 for a costed list of measures to act on, and Level 3 for a large capital project that needs firm numbers.

If a city or authority requires an audit, use the level named in the local rule, because the authority having jurisdiction can adjust the standard's scope and reporting.

What does ASHRAE Standard 211 cover?

ANSI/ASHRAE/ACCA Standard 211 sets consistent practices for conducting and reporting commercial building energy audits. It defines the procedures for Levels 1, 2 and 3, a common scope of work, the minimum rigour of analysis and minimum reporting requirements.

It applies to all buildings except single-family houses, multifamily structures of three stories or fewer above grade and manufactured houses. Its 2024 addendum a also adds decarbonization assessments for Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions.

Does an ASHRAE audit cover industrial processes?

No. Standard 211 excludes industrial processes, agricultural processes and irrigation from the end uses it covers. It applies to buildings and their systems, such as HVAC, lighting, envelope, steam and water systems.

An audit of a manufacturing site that follows the ASHRAE levels therefore needs a stated facility boundary. Agree in writing how process loads are treated, so that quotations can be compared.

Who can perform an ASHRAE energy audit?

Standard 211 defines a qualified energy auditor who certifies compliance. The definition requires experience of commercial building energy audits plus a recognised credential, a professional engineer or contractor status approved by the authority having jurisdiction, or approval by that authority.

Ask any auditor how they meet the definition and any local rule. ASHRAE publishes the standard, but compliance is attested by the auditor on the compliance form.

Is an ASHRAE energy audit mandatory?

Compliance with Standard 211 is voluntary until and unless a legal jurisdiction makes it mandatory through legislation. ASHRAE lists several United States jurisdictions that use the standard, including Washington D.C., Washington State, Oregon, Boulder, Atlanta, Philadelphia and Seattle.

Check the local rule for the required level and reporting. Outside the United States, other audit standards and rules apply.

How much data is needed for an ASHRAE energy audit?

Benchmarking under the standard uses normalised energy consumption spanning at least 12 consecutive months and up to three consecutive years, where available. It compares the building with similar buildings.

Interval data, drawings, equipment lists and operating schedules improve the analysis. Level 3 adds measured field data, including sub-metering for the target systems.

How much does an ASHRAE Level 2 energy audit cost?

There is no single price, because it depends on the size and complexity of the facility, the number of systems in scope and the distance the auditor must travel. The Department of Energy makes the same point about building complexity, size and travel.

The level matters too, since each level adds survey effort and analysis. Ask for a quotation based on a written scope that states the level, the facility boundary and the deliverables, so that offers can be compared.

Need an ASHRAE Energy Audit Scoped and Delivered?

Global Formulation provides ASHRAE Level 1, 2 and 3 energy audits, industrial utility audits and savings verification, scoped to the level and facility boundary you choose.

Discuss an Energy Audit
AK

Absar Khan

Founder & Lead Consultant, Global Formulation

Absar Khan is a senior industrial consultant with cross-disciplinary expertise spanning chemical process engineering, reaction engineering, and industrial formulation. He founded Global Formulation to provide accessible, expert-led process development and scale-up services to manufacturers and entrepreneurs in the chemical industry. Connect with him on LinkedIn.

Message on WhatsApp